
Why Trinidad and Tobago Needs Independent Evaluation of Employment Spending
October 7, 2026By Dr. C. Justine Pierre
Dr. C. Justine Pierre is a Researcher, Labour Market Statistician, and Workforce Development Consultant at DPB Global.
This article is Dr. C. Justine Pierre’s personal commentary as a Grenadian citizen. It does not represent an institutional position of Dunn Pierre Barnett and Company Canada Ltd (DPB Global).
A young person’s route from classroom to career runs through a chain of measurable events: the first job, the quality of that job, the record it leaves, and the claims governments make about creating jobs like it. In much of the Caribbean, every link in that chain is unmeasured or unverified. The first job may be informal and leave little record. Graduates may not be tracked after training. And job-creation announcements may be counted more readily than the jobs themselves. These are not separate problems. Without a record of the first job, there is less for a tracer study to find. Without tracer studies, training investment cannot be properly evaluated. And without verification, job-creation claims cannot be distinguished from announcements. The youth-to-work chain needs measurement from its first link onward.
1. The First Job Trap: Why Informal Work Locks Young Workers Out Before Their Careers Start

Informal work represents a substantial share of employment across much of the Caribbean. Young workers are often overrepresented at the point of entry: school leavers take the work available, and available work is disproportionately informal. The consequence is not simply that a first job lacks paperwork. It is that a worker can begin a career without the evidence needed to progress through it.
No contract means no record. An informal first job may produce no payslip history, social security contributions or verifiable employment reference. When a worker later applies for a formal position, the application can show an apparent gap rather than experience. Employers may not see the skills and work history already acquired.
No social security means no protection and no accumulation. Pension entitlements, injury protection and contributory benefits depend on registration and contributions. When work is unregistered, time spent working may not build a contribution record. Years of effort can therefore be missing from the protections normally associated with employment.
No certification means skills remain invisible. A young electrician, seamstress, cook or farm worker may have substantial competence acquired through experience. Without assessment or certification, employers may not recognize those abilities, and systems may not record them. Prior Learning Assessment and Recognition (PLAR) can help convert demonstrated informal experience into recognized qualifications. It makes competence visible without requiring workers to start their training journey again.
No progression means no compounding. Early-career wage growth, skill development and better job matching often happen through job changes. Those moves are more productive when each one leaves a traceable record of experience and capability. Informal work can compound negatively: the longer an informal spell continues, the harder it may be to demonstrate experience and secure a stronger next job.
The consequences extend beyond individual workers. Informality at entry suppresses the region’s measured skills supply, weakens Labour Market Information Systems (LMIS) by limiting administrative data on jobs, and blurs productivity measurement when both employment and output are undercounted. The policy implication is direct: the first job is where formality is cheapest to establish and most valuable to protect. Public employment and apprenticeship programmes should ensure that every publicly supported placement is registered, contracted and pension-linked from day one.
The paradox series treated informality as one of six drivers of youth exclusion. Here, informality is examined as the entry-point problem that can shape the entire chain.
2. Graduate Tracer Studies: The Five-Question Survey Every Government Should Run Every Year

A graduate tracer study is a short, recurring survey of people who completed an education or training programme, conducted twelve months or more after completion. Its purpose is to establish what happens after training, not just how many people enrolled or graduated. Five questions provide a practical foundation.
1. Where did they land?
Record employment status: employed, self-employed, in further study, unemployed, inactive or migrated. Each category matters for policy. Combining every outcome into “employed or not” destroys useful information. Migration, in particular, changes the national return on a training investment and should be measured rather than omitted.
2. In what occupation?
Record the occupation held, code it to a recognized standard and compare it with the occupation the programme prepared the graduate to enter. This reveals horizontal mismatch. A welding graduate working as a security guard may have completed training successfully, but the mismatch signals that enrolment and graduation counts alone cannot reveal whether skills are being used.
3. At what earnings?
Collect earnings in the first job and, where possible, track changes over time. Earnings help show how a programme’s outcomes align with labour-market demand. They also provide the denominator for cost-per-outcome calculations used by ministries and funders when assessing investment.
4. How long until the first job?
Measure the time between programme completion and first employment. This is a clear, practical indicator for training systems to monitor. It can help reveal where job matching is slow and where support for employer connections or transitions into work may be needed.
5. What job quality?
Record contract status, including permanent, fixed-term or informal work; social security registration; hours; and whether the job uses the skills taught. Job quality distinguishes a functioning pathway into work from a credential with nowhere to go.
A useful tracer study is short, but its design must be disciplined. The survey should be annual and cover publicly funded programmes consistently. Results should be published by programme. Participation should be voluntary, responses confidential and reporting aggregated to protect respondents.
The results support more than a graduate employment count. Earnings can feed into cost-benefit analysis of educational investment, including Net Present Value and rate-of-return work. Occupation data can inform skills-demand reporting and occupational shortage lists. Employment status and job quality provide a foundation for the verification question in the next section. Every government-funded training programme should carry a tracer study as a condition of funding, with results published annually.
3. Counting Announcements Is Not Counting Jobs: How to Verify Employment Claims Against Payroll Records

Governments across the region announce employment initiatives. The announcements can become headlines while the jobs themselves remain uncounted. An announced job, a created job, a filled job and a sustained job are four different things. For policy evaluation, the sustained job is the more meaningful outcome.
Define the auditable job. A defensible count should identify a real paid worker, verify the employment against payroll or tax records where applicable, prevent duplicate counting, set a minimum duration and distinguish net new employment from a rehire or relabelled existing job. These rules help prevent short-lived placements, duplicate records and reclassification from being reported as new employment.
Verify registered employment against administrative records. Payroll, tax and social security records can corroborate registered wage jobs, reported wages and continuity over time. They cannot, by themselves, capture all self-employment or informal work. Announcements that cannot be reconciled with the relevant records should not be presented as verified formal jobs.
This is not an accusation against any government. It is the same audit standard that should apply to any public investment. It also protects credible programmes from comparisons based on inconsistent or inflated counts.
Report quarterly and publicly. Publish job creation by sector, gender, age and geography, with the baseline and methodology clearly stated. A quarterly series turns a political claim into a statistical series that can be examined, defended or corrected.
Account for the counterfactual. Jobs supported by public funding should be assessed against what would likely have happened without that support. This helps distinguish additional employment from deadweight or relabelling.
Verification connects directly to the first two links. It depends on administrative records, which formal work helps generate. A registered, contracted placement can be both a verifiable job in the national series and a first rung on a young worker’s career ladder. Governments that verify claims can make their case with evidence rather than volume. Citizens and political competitors gain a shared factual basis instead of competing announcements.
4. What DPB Global Brings to the Chain

DPB Global works across the measurement needs that connect youth training to employment outcomes. Its service lines include labour market assessments and employer skills-demand surveys; national skills audits; labour force surveys and household budget and living conditions surveys; and Labour Market Information Systems that link administrative records with survey data.
The firm also designs and implements graduate tracer studies, supports Competency-Based Education and Training (CBET), occupational standards and PLAR, and conducts independent evaluation and impact assessment. Its survey execution spans more than 40 countries, with specialization in data on Black, Indigenous and People of Color (BIPOC), diaspora and other racialized populations.
These capabilities can be designed as one integrated system. Survey infrastructure can measure informality, tracer studies can follow training outcomes, and evaluation can develop verification methods for employment claims. Together, they connect the worker’s experience with the evidence governments need to assess workforce development.
5. The Chain, Made Measurable

A stronger youth-to-work chain has three measurable links: a registered first job, an annual graduate tracer study and a verified job series. Each helps address a different gap. Together, they turn longstanding ambiguities in Caribbean labour market policy into published evidence.
Building these measurement systems requires investment, but the cost should be considered against the programmes they are meant to evaluate. Without reliable records, decision-makers cannot confidently compare what training costs with what it delivers, or distinguish sustained employment from an announcement.
DPB Global supports governments, development partners and organizations with labour market assessments, tracer studies, skills audits, Labour Market Information Systems and independent evaluation. Organizations seeking to measure any link in the youth-to-work chain can contact the firm at dpbglobal1.com.
About the Author
Dr. C. Justine Pierre is a Researcher, Labour Market Statistician, and Workforce Development Consultant at Dunn Pierre Barnett and Company Canada Ltd (DPB Global), specializing in labour market trends, data-driven policy, and economic justice for BIPOC communities globally.
About DPB Global
Dunn Pierre Barnett and Company Canada Ltd (DPB Global) is a premier full-service consulting firm specializing in Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET), Competency-Based Education and Training (CBET), Labour Market Research and Social Surveys, and Workforce Development. With global expertise in Instructional Design, Management Consulting, Capacity Building, and Business Development, the firm maintains one of the world’s largest databases on Black Data and populations in the Global South, providing expert insights and AI-driven analytics to support diverse communities, governments, and organizations across Canada, Africa, and the Americas. Visit us at dpbglobal1.com.



